Watch Court TV Legendary Trials with Fubo
Plans start at $79.99/mo
Additional taxes, fees and regional restrictions may apply.
See the trials that captivated the world and made history! Join your favorite Court TV hosts, Vinnie Politan, Julie Grant, Michael Ayala, Ted Rowlands and Ashley Willcott, and witness all the dramatic moments streaming on Court TV Legendary Trials.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP29 "Misdiagnosis"The jury listened to more of the mental health evaluation conducted on the defendant. Dr. Jason Pickett claimed that not only did the defendant know what she was doing when she killed her mom, Ashley Smylie, she was deceitful and manipulative in what she did and tried to get out of any responsibility for it. In his detailed 85-page mental health report, Dr. Pickett claimed Carly Gregg was misdiagnosed by a child and adolescent psychiatrist who determined that she had bipolar 2 disorder.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP30 "Closing Arguments"Closing arguments began after the State's psychiatrist wrapped up his testimony. Carly Gregg was just a 14-year-old teen when she killed her mom, Ashley Smylie. Prosecutors charged her as an adult. Instead of taking the State's plea deal, Gregg was confident that they could convince jurors that she was mentally ill when she killed her mom. If convicted she faced life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP31 "Mental Illness Took Over"It was the Defense's turn to deliver closing arguments to jurors. This was the final time Carly Gregg's attorneys would address the jury trying to convince them that she was mentally ill when she killed Ashley Smylie, her mom. Her team reiterated their point that Gregg dealt with a mental health crisis at the time of the murder and, therefore, did not know the wrongfulness of her actions.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP30 "Closing Arguments"Closing arguments began after the State's psychiatrist wrapped up his testimony. Carly Gregg was just a 14-year-old teen when she killed her mom, Ashley Smylie. Prosecutors charged her as an adult. Instead of taking the State's plea deal, Gregg was confident that they could convince jurors that she was mentally ill when she killed her mom. If convicted she faced life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP137 "Detective Lieutenant Brian Tully"Investigators looking into John O'Keefe's death seemed confident in their conclusion that Karen read fatally hit her boyfriend with her SUV and then drove away. On the stand was Detective Lieutenant Brian Tully of the Massachusetts State Police. He who supervised this case. The early part of this murder investigation included search warrants, multiple interviews, seizing key evidence, and thoroughly examining the crime scene.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP138 "Cellphone Data Info"The jury again got a glimpse at crime scene photos and surveillance video that had been collected. On the stand was a detective-lieutenant who supervised the entire murder case. Investigators used cell phone information to pinpoint the location of the victim as well as the defendant, in the hours leading up to the alleged murder. Digital technology was important for police to corroborate not just where John O'Keefe was, but also who he was communicating with and how.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP139 "Defending The State Police"Detective Lieutenant Brian Tully corroborated the digital evidence in this case. This witness was one of two supervisors of the lead detective, a key state witness. Under cross-examination Tully went over police procedures that he and his team employed throughout this murder investigation. The Defense pointed the finger at the entire Massachusetts State Police for mishandling and even corrupting this murder investigation.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP140 "Corroborating Digital Evidence"Karen Read's attorney had more questions for the detective-lieutenant. Brian Tully was one of two supervisors overseeing the investigation into John O'Keefe's death. On the stand, he testified about the physical evidence collected at the crime scene. Things got technical with this state trooper. Jurors learned about GPS data linked to cell phone information retrieved by investigators.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP17 "A Fatal Mental Health Crisis"Jurors got the full mental health report on Carly Gregg. On the stand was Dr. Andrew Clark, a child and adolescent psychiatrist. The defendant was only 14 when police said she killed her mother, Ashley, and tried to kill her stepdad. According to the report, Carly Gregg was dealing with a mood disorder which was exacerbated by the medication she was wrongly taking. The Defense wanted to show jurors that Gregg was dealing with a mental health crisis in the lead-up to the murder.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP18 "Psychiatrist Under Cross-Examination"The cross-examination began on the mental health expert who evaluated Carly Gregg for four hours. Her defense was blaming mental illness for the shooting death of her mother. But the state wanted to show that this was a premeditated murder. According to child psychiatrist Dr. Andrew Clark, it was reasonable for Gregg to have no memory of the shooting claiming that such amnesia would, indeed, be convenient for the Defense's case.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP19 "Dissecting The Doctor's Report"Prosecutors challenged the mental health evaluation of Carly Gregg done by a child psychiatrist. The Defense was trying to convince jurors that she was not responsible for killing her mom because she was dealing with an untreated mental illness. The State pushed back on Gregg's alleged mental health issues saying Dr. Andrew Clark's report and testimony happened to be very convenient for her defense.
Deadly Daughter Murder Trial
S1, EP20 "State Gives Rebuttal Case"The final witness for the defense wrapped up his testimony. Carly Gregg's attorneys rested their case-in-chief, convinced that they gave enough evidence about her mental state, which they contended led to her fatally shooting her mother. Next, the State began its rebuttal case with a nurse practitioner, who evaluated and prescribed medication to the defendant weeks before the murder and attempted murder.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP125 "Lead Investigators Clear Things Up"Defense attorney Alan Jackson alleged that police manipulated video involving Karen Read's car. He was trying to raise doubts about law enforcement's handling of key evidence in this case. Sergeant Yuri Bukhenik admitted to jurors that the video was, in fact, inverted. But during redirect examination, he tried to clear things up dismissing the allegation that the video was intentionally manipulated and altered. Next, to the stand was Trooper Michael Proctor, the lead investigator on the case.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP126 "Trooper Michael Proctor"The lead investigator in the murder investigation of a 16-year Boston police officer took the stand. Massachusetts State Police Trooper Michael Proctor told jurors how he initially got involved and took over this case. Jurors learned how Massachusetts State Police began its investigation into John O'Keefe's death. Just hours after he was killed, police interviewed Karen Read at her parents' home and seized her cell phone and car.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP127 "Early Into The Murder Investigation"Michael Proctor was a key witness in this trial for both sides. For the State, he was in charge of the entire murder investigation. But according to the Defense, he was part of a massive cover-up which led to Karen Read on trial for murder. After getting initial statements from the defendant and the victim's friends, Trooper Proctor recalled that he and his team used search warrants to seize surveillance video and Karen Read's SUV.
Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
S1, EP128 "A State Trooper's Family Ties And Social Connections"Prosecutors brought up the family members of State Trooper Michael Proctor. Why? Because the Defense had tried to raise doubts on how sensitive information about John O'Keefe's death had been shared among family members, friends, and neighbors involved in this investigation. This case focused on more than just the physical evidence in the death of John O'Keefe. At issue was how police handled that evidence as well as the very conduct of the investigators was key.
Popular on Court TV Legendary Trials
Included with Fubo
